What Stops Most Writers (It Isn't Talent)

Too many ideas, too much research, and the gap between the book in your head and the page.

I have been writing stories since I was a kid. In my twenties, that grew into journalism, PR, book publishing, and social media content, and today I write both nonfiction and fiction. It is the third week of Novel November, and I am writing my first novel, the start of a series.

My own draft is a good example of what week three does. I have too many ideas, and I swing between not being focused enough and being so focused on a single detail that the page count barely moves. This article looks at what actually stalls a draft, which is rarely talent, using my own stalls as examples, and at what helps you keep going.

The book in your head

Talent helps you begin, but it does not decide who finishes. What stops most of us is the gap between the book we can see and the draft that exists. In your head, the story is whole. You know what the reader will feel, what the characters need to discover, or why a particular memory belongs in the chapter. Then you sit down to write it, and the scene arrives thinner than it looked, the argument is less clear than it sounded, and the chapter you planned for an afternoon takes most of a week.

For me, the gap looks different depending on what I am writing. In my fiction, the gap is too many ideas, so the story in my head is huge and branching and whatever I get onto the page feels like one thin thread of it. In my nonfiction, the gap is too much research and information, and the hard part is deciding what belongs on the page and what only I need to know.

That gap is not proof the project was a mistake. It is the distance between an idea and something another person can read, and every finished book has crossed it. A finished concept and a finished manuscript are two different things, and plenty of writers only discover what they are trying to say once they have started saying it badly.

Fiction and nonfiction stall in different places

In fiction, the trouble often starts when the story stops following the outline. A character will not do what you planned, a scene turns out to belong somewhere else, or the world needs a rule you have not decided yet. In nonfiction, the trouble usually starts when the facts, or the people in them, push back. A date does not match the record, two memories disagree, or the argument you were sure of has a hole in it.

My own stalls come from my training. Genealogy, journalism, and PR taught me to research, chase details, and confirm sources, and those habits serve nonfiction well. In fiction, they can become a distraction, because a story needs momentum before it needs a footnote. My publishing background adds a second pull. Because of my acquisitions and agency work and my years in PR, my head runs ahead to the behind-the-scenes side of making a book successful and marketing it, long before the book exists.

The cure for both kinds of stall is less different than you would think. In each case, the problem has a specific name, and it is rarely that you are not good enough.

When polishing replaces writing

Another stall looks like diligence. You go back to fix the opening, and the week that should have produced new pages produces a better first chapter instead. That is not my problem yet, because I am still struggling to get enough written, but I have edited and proofread long enough to know how the trap works. Revision is real work, and caring about quality is not the problem. The problem is asking one stage of the process to do the job of every stage at once.

Drafting develops the material. Revision looks at its shape and meaning. Editing sharpens the language, and proofreading catches what is left. They overlap, but they are not interchangeable, and trying to perfect every sentence while the story is still forming can burn a month without fixing the thing that is actually wrong.

When the story is about real people

Memoir and family history carry extra weight, and I know it from my own family research. I am not a sensationalist. I prefer accuracy, but accurate does not mean that everything I know needs to be told. In my family's history, I have heard and found information that could be considered embarrassing, scandalous, or hurtful to the living, and some of it truly is.

When there are living relatives involved, I try to talk with them to see where they stand on sharing it. Sometimes I put an embargo on myself and my notes, so nothing is widely shared until a certain time. None of that has to stop you from drafting. You can write a passage and mark a fact to verify, set down two differing recollections without pretending they match, or admit a memory is incomplete instead of filling the hole with an assumption. The draft is often what shows you which questions are worth chasing down, and which stories are yours to tell and when.

What to do the day it stops

Start by naming the real obstacle, because different problems need different fixes. If the problem is time, a smaller session you can keep beats a grand schedule you cannot. If it is structure, try an outline or a list of unanswered questions. If it is research, mark the gap and keep moving. If the manuscript has grown beyond what you can see clearly on your own, a trusted reader or an editor can show you what is working.

When I hit a wall, I have to step away and clear my head, and the same goes for being overwhelmed by too many ideas or too much information. It is like working a jigsaw puzzle or a word search. If you search so hard for the missing piece that you cannot see anything else, you have to relax your eyes, or your head, before it shows up. Sometimes I listen to music, often instrumental, and sometimes I crochet a pattern I know by heart so my hands stay busy and my mind is free.

And when you reach the scene you cannot get right, lower the standard for this draft only. Write a note to yourself about what has to happen there, skip to the next scene you can see, and keep going. If you have to write it badly, write it badly and all the way through. A flawed scene can be revised, but a scene that was never written leaves you nothing to work with. The difference between a placeholder and an avoided problem is that you come back to the placeholder.

A word to student writers

Today is International Students Day, observed every November 17 in memory of the Czech students and teachers who resisted the Nazi occupation of Prague in 1939. It has since become a day to recognize students everywhere. If you are a student writer reading this, the path from a story to a published book has more barriers for some writers than for others, and I would rather say that plainly than leave it out.

The draft is the part you control, and a finished one belongs to you no matter what comes next. Write the story first, and we can work out the rest together, from finding readers to finding a path to publication.

CLOSING TAKEAWAY

Talent is not what decides whether a manuscript gets finished. Too many ideas, too much research, a sentence you will not leave alone, or a wall you keep pushing against instead of stepping away from will stall a draft far more often, and each one has a fix you can start on today. Name the obstacle, write the scene badly if you have to, and step back when pushing harder stops working. The manuscript does not need to be good this week. It needs to exist, because everything else comes after.

WORTH NOTING

For nonfiction of any kind, William Zinsser's On Writing Well is a long-standing guide to writing clearly and cutting what does not belong, which helps when your research has given you more than a chapter can hold. John McPhee's Draft No. 4 is a collection of essays on the writing process, including how he organizes large amounts of material into a structure.

For fiction, Stephen King's On Writing is part memoir and part craft guide, with plain advice on getting a first draft down. Anne Lamott's Bird by Bird is a candid, funny look at the rough first draft that applies to fiction and nonfiction alike. Check current editions at your library or bookstore.

Kelly Howard

Founder and CEO, Vysyons Communications

VysyonsCommunications.com

KWBHoward@VysyonsCommunications.com

If you are stuck on a manuscript, memoir, or family history, Vysyons Communications offers a free 20-minute Discovery Call to talk through what the project needs next: www.VysyonsCommunications.com/discovery-call

Next
Next

When the Story Moves Faster Than the Facts